Sally plans to use the challenge at the start of each course. The intent is to show students the power of a the mind when it comes to food preferences/tolerances. After all, "food isn't nutritious if it isn't eaten," says Brian Wansink in this article.
What a recovering picky eater pledge needs to do
1. Think about all the foods you've hated forever.
2. Pick one. A nutritious one (no, bagels don't count as nutritious). You will be using your brain and the way you think about food to change your mindset about that food, it's texture, smell, taste. You will be digging into the "why" it is repulsive to you, and replace the negative thoughts you have about the food with positive ones.
3. Eat your challenge food at least once a week. Keep trying new recipes, preparations until you find one that isn't repulsive. Mindset shifts take time. If it doesn't work on the first try, keep trying. Here is some reading that will help you make the mindshift.
- Find A Way to Like Food You Hate - Actionable Steps to Take
- Bend your Mind, Like a New Food - Create new positive thoughts about a food you hate
What counts as "nutritious"?
Fruits, vegetables, nuts/seeds, animal proteins, dairy, healthy fats (coconut oil, olive oil, fats from animal products if the animals eat their natural diet and are raised organically) are all nutritious. The average American already over consumes soy, corn, wheat, grains, so do your health a favor and don't challenge with one of those items. Do your health a favor and get organic animal products if budget allows. If you're not sure if your challenge food is nutritious leave a comment and I'll advise.
Try not to challenge a "reactive" food. Sometimes we avoid reactive food in childhood because they make us feel bad. Your brain is smart. It will protect you even in childhood, if you listen. Eating reactive foods (also called food in tolerances) causes inflammation in the gut. You don't want to inflame your gut. Your gut is the only vehicle you have to nourish your cells, when it's inflamed you can't get nutrients to your cells and organs and they start malfunctioning. The malfunction may seen benign at first but over time it builds up can cause some annoying disorders like migraines, allergies, asthma, learning/attention disorders, mental health deficiencies, constipation, IBS, diarrhea and more. So listen to your body. If your eczema gets itchier, your throat feels scratchy, your nose gets congested or your notice your tummy is roiling after you eat your challenge item, that's a good sign to discontinue it, at least temporarily. For example, I recently discovered that conventional strawberries are reactive for me. Organic berries don't make me react, but conventional ones do. I'm guessing the pesticides used during their cultivation are irritants to my immune system and cause nasal congestion and a flare up of eczema.
Most hated foods are not reactive foods
More often than not you have avoided a food in childhood for other reasons that to avoid inflammation and tummy distress. You avoided a food because you couldn't tolerate the texture, smell or taste. Or it was introduced to you during some time of distress (health or emotional). Your brain linked the food with the distress, when really there is no link. Or you didn't have a real food advocate in your life and so no one ever taught you that yes, indeed you really do need to eat real nutrients to fuel your body or your body can perform and function optimally. If your parents took the "they'll eat it if they want it" route and never really expected you to eat protein, fat, fruits and vegetables you may have grown up eating on the foods you wanted to eat, instead of the foods that would fuel your body for a well life. Don't worry, it's never too late to learn to like real food. Even the pickiest eaters can reform. I did. You can too. The good news is, you can say good bye to annoying conditions like IBS and trouble maintaining weight, just by eating more real food and less processed food.
Will you Pledge to become a Recovering Picky Eater?
Are you with me? Are you tired of saying "no tomatoes" to the waiter when ordering a side salad at a restaurant? Are you ready to leave the hypocrisy bag behind when you serve veggies to your kids but won't eat them yourself? Are you ready to stop avoiding baked chicken because the bones creep you out? Are you ready to embrace the mouth feel of raw crunchy carrots or nuts? Is there a dish your spouse loves that you can stand because it contains onions or a feared vegetable from childhood? If you are ready to leave your picky eater label behind, leave a comment on this blog post in this format:
Hi, I'm (your name). I pledge to learn to like (disliked food item) in the recovering picky eater challenge.To leave a comment, scroll down to the bottom of this article, click the comment link that looks like this
0 comments
Disclaimer : Forgive typos, kids are ravenous, gotta get started on breakfast, I'm already a week late on this deadline, it's publish now or drop the ball.


Hi, I'm Sally. I pledge to learn to like Brussels sprouts in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge. I tried them the last time around and my stomach turned after one bite. But that was with steamed Brussels sprouts. This time I'm trying a salad made with fresh shredded Brussels sprouts, cheese, and a lovely dressing.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Dylan. I pledge to learn to like spinach in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge.
ReplyDeleteHi Im Josh and I pledge to eat asparagus! This will be a tough one!
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Chelsea I pledge to learn to like grapes in the recovering picky eater challenge.
ReplyDeleteHi I'm Kayla and I pledge to learn to like green beans in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge.
ReplyDeletechelsea - try popping clean grapes in the freezer. eat them frozen. they taste like little stickless popsicles. fun snack for tv night.
ReplyDeletehttp://foodwithkidappeal.blogspot.com/2010/09/frozen-fruit-kids-favorite-summer-snack.html
kayla - my kids and i adore green beans blanched and dipped in ranch. if you like crunchy veggies you'll like green beans cooked this way. a co-worker gave hubs some fresh green beans from the garden, i'll blanch them for a crunchy after school snack. http://foodwithkidappeal.blogspot.com/2009/08/quick-summer-market-meal-green-beans.html
josh - asparagus is so good on the grill. only try fresh asparagus, the stuff in the can is not fit for human consumption. wash, snap off ends, toss on the grill until their color changes to a brighter green, take off, drizzle with olive oil, sea salt and fresh ground black pepper, mmmm. be careful not to over cook.
dylan - is your issue with spinach texture or flavor? your answer will help me suggest a way to prepare it that could be pleasant. spinach changes flavor and texture depending on whether it's raw or cooked. if both raw and cooked applications fail, you can always throw it in a blender with a banana, frozen berries and yogurt for a green smoothie. i suspect you'll barely notice the spinach.
happy sampling brave RPE challengers! look forward to hearing your progress sunday. come to the FB page Sunday to share success, obstacles and get more tips.
My son will eat green beans when I cook them with 'real' bacon bits. It's not as healthy as it could be but he eats them. He will also eat just about anything dipped in ranch dressing. So maybe try a low fat or fat free dressing as a dipping sauce!
ReplyDeleteAlso raw baby spinach as a salad with sliced strawberries and almonds, covered in a raspberry vinaigrette, is very good.
Hi, I'm Jessie and I pledge to learn to enjoy tomatoes in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge!
ReplyDeleteI pledge to eat peas. I have never liked peas, but I'm going to try again!
ReplyDelete--Dane Cook (NUTR 128)
Ellen Burchett pledges to try to eat veggie burgers.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Kylie. I pledge to learn to like fish in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge.
ReplyDeleteI'm Katie and I pledge to eat bananas, I've hated them since I was little...
ReplyDeleteI'm Krista and I pledge to eat fish. I have disliked fish my whole life.
ReplyDeleteI'm Nan and I pledge to eat spinach in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge. My dad likes it and always tries to get me to eat it but I have never given it a chance. -Nutrition 128.
ReplyDelete@dane - don't try peas in a can. get a bag of frozen green peas. try them frozen. my toddlers loved them frozen. if that doesn't work, drop frozen peas into a bowl of hot soup. it cools your soup down, and heats the peas up so they are still crisp. another option is to add frozen peas to cooked rice for about 2 minutes at the end of cooking. You just want to take the chill off the peas and heat them up. cooking peas too long makes them mushy and gross. good luck :)
ReplyDeleteHi! My name is Mary and I pledge to eat beans. I don't like any beans in general unless they are Bush's baked beans smothered in brown sugar and butter, lol. I would love to learn to like beans and use them as a healthy source of protien!
ReplyDeleteMary Hughes
Hi my name is Sandra and I pledge to eat more celery in the picky eater challenge.
ReplyDeleteHi! My name is Maureen and I pledge to eat sweet potatoes for the picky eater challenge. Just found some recipes to try at EatingWell.com. My family doesn't know it, but they're in it too!! :)
ReplyDeleteI'm Rose and I pledge to eat greens such as Collard Greens, Mustard Greens and Kale. My husband makes them once in awhile and would probably make them more often if I would eat them, too. He really likes them.
ReplyDeleteHi I'm Kayla and I pledge to learn to like green beans. I have never liked them and just the smell makes it difficult for me to even try. I will learn how to like them though!
ReplyDeleteHi I'm Kelsey and I pledge to eat tomatoes in the Recovering Picky Eater Challenge. The texture is the issue in this sitation so if I can get past that, hopefully the taste won't be too bad!
ReplyDeleteHey, this is Jessica Cordle and my food for the Picky Eater Challenge I have chose Cottage Cheese. With this I was going to try to mix in some healhy items such as peaches or pineapple. The texture is my ultimate problem.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Leah and i pledge to eat green peas in The Recovering Picky Eater Challenge.I don't like them because they are soft and mushy.
ReplyDeleteHi this is Ellen Burchett on week 2 of the picky eater challenge. I tried veggie burgers again this week. This week I ate the veggie burger on bread just like a burger with mayo and lettuce and I have to say it was better this time. It still doesn't really compare to a hamburger though. Last week I just tried the veggie burger plain.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Heather, and I pledge to learn to like peas in The Recovering Picky Eater Challenge. I've never liked peas, but I'll give it a shot again.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Jennifer. I pledge to learn to like fish in the recovering picky eater challenge.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm Wendy. I pledge to learn to like lobster. I like fish but that's it and I know seafood is realy good for you. I'm going to start with lobster for this challenge. I don't like the taste or texture of it. I tried lobster with butter week 1 and could hardly swallow it. Week 2 I tried lobster bisque and was actually able to tolerate a small cup of it.
ReplyDeleteHello this is Randi Hall and I have never liked to eat peas from birth until now. I am going to start eating peas, one because they are good for you and two, I need to start watching what I eat at the age of 44!
ReplyDeleteHello, Im Dane, and on week two when I tried to eating peas from a can, because I had not yet seen your reply that I shouldnt eat them out of a can. You were right. They still werent very good.
ReplyDeleteDane Cook (NUTR128)
Hello, Its Dane again. Week 3 of my challenge, I decided to follow your instructions of eating them frozen. They werent terrible, but still not something that I would choose to eat regularly.
ReplyDeleteDane Cook (NUTR128)
Hello this is Randi, and I just wanted to say that I ate peas for the first time yesterday and it's been a long time! I heated them up on the stove and put "I cant believe it's not butter" on them and they weren't that bad actually! Thanks to the Picky Eater Challenge!
ReplyDeletehi I'm Rian and I hate onions. So that's what I have tried to eat for these past weeks and I have come to find that I don't hate them as much as I used to. I just have chop them up really little so that I can't really notice that it is in my food. for an example putting it in chili or on a pizza. My boss at work did that to me one day. Thanks to the picky eaters challenge!
ReplyDeleteThis is Dane Cook again, and you were right, putting them in hot soup helped cool my soup down, but also heat up the peas. I put them in cream of broccoli soup, and i couldn't even hardly taste them. Just the way I liked it. If I ever had to eat peas again, this is the way to do it.
ReplyDeletethanks for your help!
Dane Cook (NUTR 128)
dane- awesome! rian - i was shocked to learn i didn't actually hate onions. after 3 years of being back on "onions" i can eat them raw or as a side dish. i'm making slow cooked onions in chicken stock tomorrow, yum! randi- huzzah for pea acceptance, try real butter next time! when was the last time your read the ingredient list for "i can't believe it's not butter?" you guys can leave a comment here about recent RPEC adventures http://www.facebook.com/pages/Food-With-Kid-Appeal/441147605034#!/permalink.php?story_fbid=135125849895447&id=441147605034
ReplyDeleteThank you, thats very interesting information. I need to share with my friends.
ReplyDelete